The Detroit city council approved the Red Wings‘ new lease on Joe Louis Arena yesterday, but only by a 5-4 margin, as some councilmembers raised concerns about the deal, which sets the stage for the old arena to be torn down once a new one is built. In particular:
- Mary Sheffield voted against the lease because she felt the $5 million the city will be getting from Red Wings owner Mike Ilitch to pay off 30 years of back cable rights fees that he failed to share with the city at the time is insufficient.
- Raquel Castañeda-López and Scott Benson voted against the lease because it contains a non-compete clause that prevents the city from selling tickets to any events at Joe Louis once the Red Wings leave. If the city isn’t able to redevelop the old arena site, warned Benson, “the building stays there and we’re not able to use it as an arena. There’s just so much risk there: It becomes a white elephant — blighted, damaged, vandalized.”
City COO Gary Brown, meanwhile, responded that Detroit needs to look forward, not backward: “We’re getting a brand-new stadium, and we can’t go back and undo the past. Let’s move forward and get the city moving again.” Yeah, the past — what’s it good for, anyway?