One proposal floated at the Capitol would allow from $350 million to $750 million to be generated for an arena from sales and excise taxes imposed within a new taxing district. The plan, detailed in a 49-page draft bill obtained by The Republic, also could allow public funds to be used to build a hotel or other commercial real estate within the district, according to those who have examined the proposal…
The team would contribute $100 million to $170 million toward any project, according to Anthony LeBlanc, the team’s president and chief executive. He said the franchise is looking to build on 50 to 60 acres.
Suddenly, all of LeBlanc’s “we’re gonna build a new arena somewhere that’ll make us more money than playing in our already-built arena without that sweet $8-million-a-year subsidy we’ve been getting” talk makes sense: If they’re getting as much as $750 million in state tax money to build an arena, and maybe a whole bunch of commercial and hotel development on 50 acres of surrounding property, the team owners can put it pretty much anywhere and it’ll turn a profit. Hell, it might be a good deal even if nobody goes to Coyotes games, which is probably the business model that LeBlanc is looking at anyway.
Makes sense for the team owners, I should say, not for the state, for which a giant tax-increment financing district makes absolutely zero sense. For, say, Mesa or Glendale to devote tax dollars to a new arena is at least arguable, since they can hope to steal some consumer spending from the next town over. (This figure is usually overblown, but at least it’s non-zero.) For the state of Arizona, though, the benefits are as close to zero as possible: Hardly anybody ever travels to Arizona just to see a Coyotes game, which means any sales tax money that would be siphoned off to the team’s owners would be money that otherwise would be collected somewhere else in the state — in Glendale currently, but scattered all over the state even in the event that the Coyotes were to leave Arizona entirely and people went back to spending their Coyotes ticket money on whatever they did before the Coyotes arrived.
The tax-subsidy bill is currently stalled in the Arizona legislature as this session runs out the clock, but LeBlanc has vowed to bring it back up in 2017. There may well be an announcement by the Coyotes in coming weeks of a preferred arena site, but make no mistake, that’s going to be the sideshow: Keep your eyes on this TIF district, because when it comes to taxpayer costs, it’s likely to be the main event.