Could an indy league revive Hagerstown’s stadium after MLB consigned the Suns to oblivion?

Reporting on plans for what to do with stadiums in the 18 cities that were completely jettisoned from minor-league baseball (separate from the 25 additional cities that are having their paid players replaced by college interns) has been sadly lacking since last months’ hit list announcement, likely because most news media in 2021 has the attention span of a gnat and the budget of one as well. But yesterday there was some news from Hagerstown, where the Suns have been dematerialized after 40 years, leaving behind a stadium that has hosted pro ball on and off since 1930, with several renovations along the way.

The Hagerstown city council held a work session on Tuesday to explore the options, and they are, in order of appearance in the Herald-Mail, the newspaper of the Maryland-Pennsylvania-West Virginia conjunction:

  • Host some “cost-neutral local events, such as high school baseball games” or concerts.
  • Build an indoor turf facility there (likely looking something like this), so locals don’t have to travel elsewhere for sports like youth soccer.
  • Bring in a baseball team in an independent league, two of which have contacted city officials already about using its existing stadium.

All these are reasonable ideas, as is surveying local residents about their preference before moving ahead with any of them. Mayor Emily Keller said that she doesn’t want to cost local residents more money, which also sounds good; there’s also the issue of who would staff games or concerts, since the city doesn’t have staff available. (Hopefully event organizers could either bring their own staff or pay enough of a fee for the city to hire some workers.)

The indy-league baseball option is especially interesting, not so much because it’s necessarily the best one, but because there’s been so much speculation that running unaffiliated minor-league teams wouldn’t be sustainable; one exec of an eliminated minor-league team told me his organization’s research showed it would take a guaranteed 3,000 tickets sold per game just to break even. If two independent leagues are at least sniffing around — the Atlantic League has to be one, thanks to its geography and the fact that it only has six teams currently including the newly created Gastonia Honey Hunters — that’s a good sign that maybe indy leagues will fill some of the vacuum left by the contraction of the affiliated minors.

All this would be significantly easier if North American baseball ran more like European soccer, with promotion and relegation, so that Hagerstown could just find some local willing to sponsor a semi-pro team and then watch it try to win its way back up to the professional ranks. That still wouldn’t be perfect, though — somebody has to buy enough tickets to pay the ticket takers and pay for turning the lights on — so if indy leagues can fill a similar role, that’s better than nothing. It will be very interesting to see how this unfolds as the season approaches, depending on when and if coronavirus levels decline enough for that to even happen.

 

Share this post:

4 comments on “Could an indy league revive Hagerstown’s stadium after MLB consigned the Suns to oblivion?

  1. 4 of the 18 dropped MiLB teams have already found homes:
    – Tri-City ValleyCats: independent Frontier League
    – Batavia Muckdogs: summer-college PGCBL
    – Clinton LumberKings: summer-college Prospect League
    – Burlington Bees: summer-college Prospect League

    1. Don’t forget the Boise Hawks…
      https://www.ktvb.com/article/sports/baseball/hawks/minor-league-baseball-mlb-team-cut-pioneer-league/277-2cc71e87-394c-48ed-a757-733c3f24268e

      I’m sure not all teams will find new homes, but the ones which ran as actual businesses rather than plaything for local rich guy will likely find an opportunity somewhere.

      Some will have to move a rung or two down the talent ladder to support themselves on the fanbase they have, but it doesn’t have to be the end of the line for them.

  2. Based on the Suns flagging attendance in recent year it doesn’t look promising at all for them to make 3,000 per game in attendance. See linked article,

    https://www.heraldmailmedia.com/news/local/hagerstown-suns-tourism-official-expect-attendance-to-rebound-after-slow-start/article_36f7f28d-c2d8-59ae-90bf-b7371275a66c.html

  3. my guess is they really mean “summer wood bat leagues” since that’s not listed separately.

    the Atlantic just left another ex affiliated market in New Britain, which had far better support than Hagerstown. my guess is any pro league would be interested only if they needed a base for a temporary road team.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*
*

801,047 Spambots Blocked by Simple Comments