The New York city council is gearing up for another run at Madison Square Garden’s 32-year-old full property tax exemption, and the city’s Independent Budget Office has a new estimate of how much MSG’s owners will get from it: $54 million in 2015, based on the projected increased value of a renovated Garden. The total value of MSG’s exemption now stands at a whopping $541 million*.
While the IBO doesn’t make policy recommendations, it just presents policy options, economist George Sweeting makes it pretty clear what the agency thinks of the MSG tax break, noting that “there is broad consensus within the economics field that government subsidies for sports facilities are not an effective use of scarce public resources,” that the Garden’s is the only property-tax exemption that applies only to a single property and is open-ended (most other property tax breaks end after a number of years, but the state legislature neglected to include a sunset provision in this case), and any threat that may have existed in 1982 of the Knicks and Rangers leaving town has long since gone by the wayside.
Of course, the council already voted once before to axe the MSG tax break, in 2008, but it didn’t accomplish anything because the tax exemption is enshrined in state law, it’s impossible to get the New York state legislature to do anything, really. Unless you’re a rich guy looking for a tax break, in which case the three men in a room would be happy to serve you.
*[UPDATE: IBO confirms that $541 million is the present value of the tax exemption over the next 30 years, net of tax breaks that would be available to any company, not just MSG. So allowing the tax break to remain in place for another 30 years would cost New York City $541 million in present-value 2014 dollars.]