This is an archived version of a Field of Schemes article. Comments on this page are closed. To find the current version of the article with updated comments, click here.
June 13, 2004
Build it, and Jim Thome will come
Carl Pohlad's pet columnist Sid Hartman is keeping up the drumbeats for a new Minnesota Twins stadium, pointing to the Philadelphia Phillies' signing of free agents Jim Thome and trades for high-priced pitchers Eric Milton, Billy Wagner, and Kevin Millwood as a sign of "what a franchise can do when it gets a new stadium."
Hartman fails to mention that all those high-priced acquisitions still haven't let the Phils catch the stadium-deprived Florida Marlins. As of this morning's standings, in fact, of the six division-leading teams, exactly zero are playing in new stadiums. And of the six last-place teams, three (Seattle, Pittsburgh, and Colorado) have moved to new taxpayer-subsidized digs in recent years. And, for that matter, the Twins (34-27) - that would be the first-place Twins - have a better record than the Phillies (31-28).
In any case, even if you concede that having more money helps teams win (or at least can't hurt), there's still the question of whether a new ballpark in itself would bring in revenues after construction costs - in which case Pohlad should just ask his old banker pals for a loan and put shovels in the ground himself - or whether it's only the public subsidies he's after that would - in which case, as a Minnesota legislator once suggested, it might be cheaper for taxpayers just to pay Brad Radke's salary.