Field of Schemes
sports stadium news and analysis


This is an archived version of a Field of Schemes article. Comments on this page are closed. To find the current version of the article with updated comments, click here.

February 08, 2007

Nets arena court battle begins, Knicks arena next?

Yesterday was the first court hearing in the battle over New Jersey Nets owner Bruce Ratner's proposed multi-billion-dollar Atlantic Yards project, which would include a basketball arena, an office skyscraper, and several apartment towers - plus the use of state eminent domain powers to seize private land, and at minimum $305 million in public "infrastructure" funds. I wasn't there, but Atlantic Yards Report's Norman Oder was, and submitted an extensive report that begins:

The marathon hearing in the Atlantic Yards eminent domain case yesterday at times felt like a law school seminar, as Magistrate Judge Robert M. Levy tossed hypothetical situations at lawyers for the plaintiffs and the defendants. Given a case that tests the boundaries of the law, Levy challenged them to suggest rules for determining when the balance of public and private purposes behind a project is so wrong that a court must intervene - and seemed unwilling to swiftly dismiss the case, as the lawyers for the defense hope.

Levy will issue his recommendation of whether to dismiss the case or allow it to continue to trial in several weeks.

Across the East River, meanwhile, there are rumblings anew of a new Madison Square Garden to be the new home of the Knicks and Rangers (and Liberty, if anyone still pays attention to them) inside the new Moynihan Station train station, which in turn would be inside the landmarked Farley Post Office building. (The current Madison Square Garden, which sits atop Penn Station, would be razed, making way for both office towers and another new station entrance.) There's nothing close to a finance plan yet, though the New York Observer's Matt Schuerman does note that new Empire State Development Corporation chief Patrick Foye has "come to believe that the private developers need to share some of the approximately $1 billion cost of ripping Penn Station open to the sky." Now all we need to know is what he means by "some."


The case will be thrown out . Can't wait to see the nets back in new york.

Posted by dan on February 9, 2007 01:02 PM

I'm surprise the Knicks hasn't filed a lawsuit or do something to stop the Nets from invading their territory and building a new arena in Brooklyn.

Then again the Knicks sucks so no one would care.

Posted by Daniel F. on February 9, 2007 06:27 PM

Daniel, your grammer needs improvement!

Posted by CK on February 10, 2007 10:32 AM

keep the nets in jersey, they have a beautiful new arena going up in newark for the devils- perfect place to play

Posted by joe on February 10, 2007 09:39 PM

Joe the nets are going to brooklyn it is a donedeal. Enough with this newark arena stuff. The nets will make alot more money in brooklyn then in newark.

Posted by Dan on February 10, 2007 10:36 PM

MSG in the Farley Post Office/Moyihan Station is a great idea guys, Jim Farley was athletic commisioner of NYS and NYS/NYC's greatest Boxing commisioner during the depression era. Since the Farley Building is a Landmark, and Farley is a Historical figure, as long as MSG recognizes its historical relation to James A. Farley and refreains from commercializing the landmarks architecture with Billboards and ads i say build it.

Posted by Mr. Democrat on February 13, 2007 11:05 AM

Latest News Items