Field of Schemes
sports stadium news and analysis


This is an archived version of a Field of Schemes article. Comments on this page are closed. To find the current version of the article with updated comments, click here.

October 04, 2010

Ratner's green-cards-for-arena-development-funds swap raises eyebrows

Even on a normal day, Norman Oder's Atlantic Yards Report is a cornucopia of information about the Brooklyn Nets arena project, often more than you really want to know in one sitting. Today, however, Oder was en fuego, reporting on the growing controversy over Nets owner Bruce Ratner's plans to raise money for construction by offering green cards to Chinese investors, which he first broke news of last week.

Today's highlights:

  • A representative of the New York firm engaged to market the investments — which, under the two-decade-old EB-5 program, which indeed offers green cards to foreign nationals who invest in the U.S. — claimed that the Barclays Center is "the most significant project in the city and state of New York in the last 20 years" and "generates well in excess of 10,000 jobs for years to come," neither of which is exactly true. The investment marketing also makes liberal use of NBA logos and Nets player photos, despite the money officially being for infrastructure on the site, not the arena itself.
  • A translation of the official Chinese website for the project reveals that, according to Oder, "immigrant investors must put in $538,000 and, after five years, get the full return of the $500,000 principal and green cards for the entire family. There's no financial gain." (It's for this reason that EB-5 has been criticized as "buying green cards.") Though the pitch does also promise signed basketballs to all takers.
  • Finally, Brooklyn Borough President Marty Markowitz, who had been schedule to make the China marketing trip with Ratner, pulled out this afternoon after criticism from both AYR and the New York Post.

While the whole mess mostly sheds light on the weirdness of U.S. immigration law — raise your hand if you had any idea that any foreigner with half a million dollars to throw around could buy their way out of waiting for resident alien status — it does indicate that Ratner and his partner Mikhail Prokhorov are looking for creative ways to find cheap money to finance development of the Atlantic Yards site. Whether that's because they're short of cash, or they just figure you can never have enough money, is anyone's guess.


I agree that the whole mess sheds light on the weirdness of U.S. immigration law, but I disagree that it "mostly" does so.

Yes, U.S. immigration law clearly has set the bar too low.

However, even with that low bar, Forest City Ratner and its allies are behaving in an extremely questionable fashion.

Posted by Norman Oder on October 4, 2010 10:58 PM

The concept of what Ratner tried to do (And I am sure others have done) is morally repulsive. Where does it stop? Al-Quida Members? Drug Kingpins? White Slavers? Spies? Gangsters? We do not need anymore of those types in this country, and it makes me wonder what is RATner all about, and to what extent will he go to get what he wants?
I never supported Develop Don't Destroy Brooklyn (I considered them "Scorched Earth" NIMBY's, who overlooked economic benefits for their narrow interests), and favored the Barkley Center for the same reason I favored Yankee Stadium and Citi Field, those areas needed cleaning up (Particularly the junk yards at Willets Point). But I have to admit I was dead wrong on this.
Trust me, characters like Ratner, Markowitz and "Don" Vito Lopez (Brooklyn Democratic Leader), will be learning a valuable lesson come election day, when hundreds if not thousands of rascals get thrown out of office nationwide (From Senators to local officials). If Obama (And what is left of the Democrats), the Republican Party, and special interests think that this is over it is not, it is just beginning. Eminent Domain, JOBS, immigration, and various bailouts (Banks, auto makers, real estate developers etc) will be the start. If nothing is done, 2012, will be even worse.

Posted by David Brown on October 5, 2010 10:04 AM

so what you are saying is that those that ignorantly call "scorched earth NIMBYs, who overlooked economic benefits for their narrow interest" were right?

Posted by fredup on October 6, 2010 06:36 PM

Here's an update on this, a series titled Anatomy of a Shady Deal:

Posted by Norman Oder on December 8, 2010 08:33 AM

Latest News Items